Thinking Properly – A Family Business Perspective

Over the Christmas period I read Daniel Kahneman’s book “Thinking, Fast and Slow” and I could relate much of what he said in this book to the unique challenges and opportunities faced by family business owners and leaders.

Kahneman’s central thesis revolves around the interplay of two cognitive systems:

  • System 1: Operates automatically, quickly, and effortlessly, relying on intuition. It is responsible for our instinctive reactions and snap judgments.
  • System 2: Engages in slower, more deliberative thinking. It is effortful, analytical and capable of overriding System 1’s impulses.

Understanding this duality is crucial for family business leaders who often grapple with complex decisions intertwined with emotional considerations. As outlined in this book, we all have several cognitive biases stemming from our reliance on System 1, which can significantly impact decision-making within a family business. Many times decision making in family business is over reliant on System 1, which brings with many problems. As family business leaders are deeply invested in their ventures, they are likely to overestimate their knowledge and control over outcomes (overconfidence bias). This can lead to risky investments, downplaying competitive threats (competition neglect), and an unwillingness to learn from past mistakes. System 1 can also be badly over influenced (availability cascade) by dramatic events, family conflicts or industry trends excessively covered in media which distort perceptions of risk and opportunity. Family businesses need to be aware of this bias and rely on data and reasoned analysis, not just readily available information, for crucial decisions. There is also the so called anchoring bias, whereby past successes, traditional practices, or strong opinions within the family can serve as anchors, unduly influencing future strategies. Leaders should actively seek diverse perspectives and challenge ingrained assumptions to avoid becoming trapped by such anchors. Another bias is loss aversion which is the fear of losing what’s been built can make family businesses overly cautious or resistant to change. This bias can hinder innovation and prevent seizing new opportunities. Acknowledging loss aversion and consciously evaluating risks and potential gains can lead to more balanced decisions.

This book underscores how the way information is presented (framing) profoundly affects choices. This is particularly relevant in family businesses where:

  • Succession planning can be either be framed as a continuation of legacy or a relinquishing of control, significantly influencing family members’ perceptions and willingness to participate.
  • Investment decisions can be framed as either potential gains or losses, impacting risk appetite and investment choices.
  • Conflict resolution can be framed as either a win-lose scenario or a collaborative effort to find mutually beneficial solutions.

Furthermore, the book emphasises the narrative fallacy, where we construct simplified, often inaccurate, stories to explain complex events. In family businesses, these narratives, rooted in family history or individual perceptions, can cloud judgment and perpetuate misunderstandings.

“Thinking, Fast and Slow” offers several strategies for navigating cognitive biases and improving decision-making, by shifting more onto System 2, through the following:-

  • Awareness: Educating family members about these biases is the first step towards mitigation. Openly discussing their potential influence in family meetings and decision-making processes can foster a more rational approach.
  • External Perspectives: Bringing in outside advisors or independent board members can introduce objectivity and challenge internal biases. They can provide alternative viewpoints and facilitate evidence-based decision-making.
  • Structured Decision Processes: Developing clear decision-making frameworks, involving data analysis, defined criteria, and a balanced consideration of risks and benefits, can help to debias choices.
  • Premortem Analysis: Encouraging a “premortem” session where members imagine a future failure of a project and identify potential causes, can surface hidden risks and mitigate overconfidence.
  • Promoting Psychological Safety: Creating a culture where individuals feel comfortable expressing doubts, challenging assumptions, and sharing different perspectives is crucial to counteract groupthink and the pressure to conform to a dominant narrative.

Family businesses often face a tension between short-term gains and long-term sustainability. This book highlights the need to:

  • Recognise the focusing illusion, where we overestimate the long-term impact of current events or decisions. This can lead to short-sighted actions that jeopardise the future of the business.
  • Cultivate a culture of patient capital, where long-term value creation takes precedence over immediate gratification. This requires clear communication of the family’s vision and values to all stakeholders.
  • Establish robust governance structures that promote transparency, accountability, and fair decision-making processes, ensuring the interests of both current and future generations are considered.

By understanding the principles of “Thinking, Fast and Slow” and applying them consciously, family business owners and leaders can make more informed, rational, and ultimately successful decisions for the long-term benefit of their businesses and families.

Leave a comment